Countering AI Sycophancy with a Devil's Advocate Plugin for Codex & Claude
Melvin Vivas · X post · 2026-10-01 · Open on X
Topics: AI Dev Tools & Productivity, AI Agents, Tool Use & MCP, Prompt & Context Engineering · Level: intermediate
Summary
Melvin Vivas noticed that Codex tends to agree with whatever he says, so he built a 'Devil's Advocate' plugin. It adds a /challenge-ideas skill that pushes back on your ideas, shows other points of view and helps you make better decisions. The plugin is in his SkillsBento plugin marketplace and installs in both the Codex CLI and Claude Code.
Key points
- AI coding assistants can be sycophantic: they often agree with the user and tell them what they want to hear.
- The Devil's Advocate plugin adds a /challenge-ideas skill that challenges your thinking and offers other perspectives.
- Codex install:
codex plugin marketplace add donvito/skillsbento, thencodex plugin add devils-advocate@skillsbento. - Claude Code install:
/plugin marketplace add donvito/skillsbento, then/plugin install devils-advocate@skillsbento. - The plugin works in both the desktop app and the CLI.
- Skills and plugin marketplaces let you share reusable agent behaviors between tools.
Resources mentioned
- skillsbento · repo · skillsbento.com · free
Melvin Vivas's GitHub plugin and skills marketplace for Codex and Claude Code, which includes the devils-advocate plugin.
Also in: Install Custom Skills in Grok Bot from a GitHub URL (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), skillsbento: Free Plugin Marketplace of Skills for Claude Code and Codex (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), SkillsBento: Free Plugin Marketplace for Codex and Claude Code (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), Agent Skill to Analyze Your X (Twitter) Analytics Export (Melvin Vivas on X · notes) and 4 more - Devil's Advocate skill · tool · skillsbento.com · free
A plugin whose skill challenges your ideas and shows other perspectives, to counter AI sycophancy.
Also in: skillsbento: Free Plugin Marketplace of Skills for Claude Code and Codex (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), SkillsBento: Free Plugin Marketplace for Codex and Claude Code (Melvin Vivas on X · notes) - OpenAI Codex · tool · openai.com · paid · recommended by both Bashiri Smith & Melvin Vivas
OpenAI's coding agent. In the diagram it writes code, fixes review findings and drives the build loop. The creator also used it to make this video.
Also in: Developers moving from ChatGPT/Codex to Claude (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), Creator Opinion: Codex Is Still the Best at Computer Use (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), OpenAI Codex Ambassador applications are open (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), GPT-Live-1.1: Multilingual Voice Update for ChatGPT and Codex (Melvin Vivas on X · notes) and 264 more - Claude Code · tool · code.claude.com · paid · recommended by both Bashiri Smith & Melvin Vivas
Build agents and pipelines from the terminal; the guide's main agentic coding tool.
Also in: First impressions: Claude Code in the cloud is good and fast (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), Why Claude Code feels faster: gzipped turns and instant cloud sessions (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), Watch What Fills Your Coding Agent's Context and When to Clear (Melvin Vivas on X · notes), Claude Code's Right Sidebar and Context Breakdown (Melvin Vivas on X · notes) and 124 more
Try this
- Add the donvito/skillsbento marketplace and install devils-advocate@skillsbento in Codex or Claude Code.
- Use /challenge-ideas to stress-test your decisions instead of accepting answers that just agree with you.
- Build your own skill or plugin that makes an AI assistant critique your ideas instead of agreeing with them.
More in AI Dev Tools & Productivity
- Customizing Your Coding Setup with Pi Coding Agent Extensions
- Pi Agent Council: Ask Multiple LLMs in Parallel and Compare Their Advice
- SkillsBento: Free Plugin Marketplace for Codex and Claude Code
- Re-authenticate the Pi Agent with the New ChatGPT Sign-In
- Grok Bot Can Now Hand Off Coding Tasks to Cursor
- jev-dev: A UI Tool to Keep Run History When Experimenting with Jev